Library book causes controversy
Save Email Print
Updated: 8:30 AM Nov 18, 2009
Library book causes controversy
The latest chapter in the continuing controversy over what children should or should not see in a public library is about to unfold in Nicholasville.
Posted: 6:53 PM Nov 17, 2009
Reporter: Denny Trease
Font Size:

The Jessamine County Library board of directors will hold an open meeting Wednesday and take comments from the public about what children should or should not be allowed to see in the library.

That follows the firing of two library workers for allegedly taking matters into their own hands to prevent what they regarded as obscene material from getting into the hands of children.

The book in question titled The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen: The Black Dossier, contains explicit sexual content including bestiality that could not be shown on TV. Library worker Sharon Cook didn't think children should be able to check it out. She says, "I was shocked. I had for some time been concerned about some of the material I saw coming through."

But when a review committee cleared the book, she simply checked it out on her own library card over and over again to keep it away from children until a computer revealed someone had put a hold on it. Cook explains, "The person it was on hold for was an 11 year old girl, and she was in line to get the book next."

So at that point co-worker Beth Boisvert decided to take the book off hold to prevent the 11 year old from getting it. She tells 27 NEWSFIRST, "To my way of thinking, the library would not have allowed an 11 year old child to have that book so I took it off hold. It was as simple as that."

Two days later, Boisvert and Cook were both fired. Boisvert says, "They told me I had practiced censorship."

At the first library board meeting after the firings, Beth and Sharon showed up to explain why the library should change it's policy on censorship, but they were not allowed to speak. Library Director Ron Critchfield defends the censorship policy by saying, "We as a library are charged with making a collection that serves multiple constituencies with multiple interests, and what might interest one person wouldn't necessarily interest someone else."

Library policy clearly states that responsibility for a child's reading must rest with the parent or guardian, not with the library. But the two workers who were fired point out that any child 11 or older can check out a book without parental consent.

Director Critchfield can not talk about the firings, but he did say he was surprised Tuesday to receive a petition saying The Black Dossier and 3 other books represent a threat to public safety.

The petition reads in part, "This community is known to have sexual predators, and works such as these encourage those predators to act out their desires or at the very least justify their desires."

Wednesday afternoon's open meeting at the library begins at 3:30.


Latest Comments

Posted by: bob Location: dole on Nov 20, 2009 at 06:46 PM

There is no god.
Posted by: jim Location: no on Nov 20, 2009 at 06:46 PM

Its a book, stop the censorship. Simple as that. also "diane" as you say kids exposed to violence etc and claim it is bad for kids and yet your bring up the amazing work of fiction known as the Bible, which as i know has: rape, murder, violence, and other horrifying acts perpetrated by man, devil, and GOD. But hey keep feeding kids [edited] and one day they to can become a dysfunctional christian member of society.
Posted by: theson Location: Lexington on Nov 20, 2009 at 05:07 PM

Moral up bringing is the responcibility of parents. If the librarians had been athiests and had done the same thing with a Bible would the situation be different? Keep your morals away from my kids. Let me choose what they can and cannot see. When it is deemed legally detrimental to a child, THEN and ONLY THEN do you have the right to inflict your moral view on my kids. If the content was inappropriate and the child accessed it there is no one to blame but the parents. And to answer the "Waa! Waa! You can't watch them all the time" comments all I can say is: pathetic. If you can't care for your children, do them a favor and put them up for adoption.

WKYT Special Sections
Classifieds
THE place to buy and sell items. Most ads free.
Half Off Deals
Save 50% from local merchants.
Desktop Alert
Download weather alerts to your computer desktop.
FirstAlert Defender
Dual Polarity Radar
Experts
Got a question? Ask our Health Experts.
WKYT Archives
Looking for a video clip?
Everyday Heroes
Is someone you know a hero?
Crime
Find out how Ray Larson is stopping crime.
Crimestoppers
Help bring criminals to justice.
Simple Energy Saving Tips
Answers to your questions about energy efficiency and saving money.
Stocks
QUOTES
    Symbol Lookup
Sponsored Headlines