After hours of deliberating, a Fayette County jury determined Dr. Michael Flick should get life in prison.
Flick was convicted of first degree murder Tuesday night, making him eligible for the death penalty.
The jury spent most of the day Wednesday listening to testimony in the sentencing phase.
Flick killed Christine Wittich and shot his former business partner Dr. Randall Lambrith in 2005.
Formal sentencing will be in February.