FRANKFORT, Ky. (AP) - Gov. Steve Beshear has granted partial
pardons to at least eight convicted murderers and 14 rapists over
the past five months, allowing them to vote and run for office.
Kentucky Department of Corrections records provided to The
Associated Press show that Beshear also granted partial pardons to
23 people convicted of felony sexual abuse.
Beshear has taken action on behalf of 747 released convicts
since March, when he streamlined the process for felons seeking to
have their civil rights restored.
"Those whose rights have been restored have served their time
and paid their debt to society," Beshear said in a written
statement. "The primary goal of the corrections system is to
rehabilitate those who have committed crimes and return them as
contributing members to society."
In Kentucky, convicted felons permanently lose their civil
rights unless the governor intervenes.
To make it easier to regain voting privileges, Beshear dropped
requirements that felons submit three letters of recommendation and
write essays explaining why their requests should be granted.
Some prosecutors object to granting the partial pardons to
people convicted of violent crimes.
"In my mind, I never believed those would be the types of
people who would be given serious consideration," said prosecutor
Linda Tally Smith, former president of the Kentucky Commonwealth's
Attorney's Association. "I would think the person who fell victim
to these offenders would expect they would continue to be treated
as the violent offenders that they are."
In his partial pardons, Beshear restored only the right to vote
and hold public office. He did not restore the right to possess
weapons or to serve on juries.
Beshear spokesman Dick Brown said Kentucky governors have been
granting partial pardons for years. Beshear's predecessor, former
Gov. Ernie Fletcher, issued more than 1,000 during his four-year
term that ended last year.
Brown said Beshear has taken an extra step, extending the period
for prosecutors to object to a request from 15 to 30 days. So far,
56 felons seeking to have their rights restored were denied when
prosecutors intervened, Brown said.
Ryan King, a policy analyst for The Sentencing Project in
Washington, said Kentucky is one of 10 states in which a felony
conviction can result in a lifetime loss of voting rights. The
others are Alabama, Arizona, Delaware, Florida, Mississippi,
Nevada, Tennessee, Virginia and Wyoming.
"It's our position that one's criminal history should have no
bearing on one's right to participate in a Democratic society,"
King said. "We believe voting is a fundamental element of any
Beshear, speaking to reporters in March, said that's also his
position. He said the process had become unwieldy and
time-consuming to the point of discouraging felons from applying.
Kentucky and Virginia, King said, have the most restrictive
process for restoring the right to vote or hold office.
Gordon Hickey, spokesman for Virginia Gov. Tim Kaine, said the
state's policy calls for each violent offender to supply three
letters of recommendation, proof of payment of all court costs and
fines, and a letter from a probation officer. An applicant must
also submit a letter explaining the circumstances of arrest and
detailing how his or her life has changed. Applicants must have
spotless records for at least five years before requesting partial
"It is a strenuous process," he said.
In Alabama, the American Civil Liberties Union filed a lawsuit
last week asking that convicted felons be allowed the right to vote
unless they were convicted of one of 15 crimes - including murder,
treason and some sex crimes - cited in state law as reasons for
In Florida, more than 115,000 former felons who completed their
sentences have had their civil rights restored since a new state
rule went into effect last year. The rule restored rights almost
automatically, ending a policy of requiring the Board of Executive
Clemency to act individually on every restoration of rights
Some Kentucky lawmakers have been pushing for a constitutional
amendment under which some felons would automatically have their
right to vote and serve in public office restored after they
complete their sentences. Those convicted of murder or sex offenses
would have been excluded under the measure that passed the House
only to die in the Senate.
If it had passed, the measure would have been put on the ballot
for Kentucky voters to ratify or reject.
State Rep. Jessie Crenshaw, D-Lexington, has pushed the
legislation in each of the past three sessions. While it failed
each time, Crenshaw said support seems to be growing.
"It is a controversial issue," Crenshaw said.
(Copyright 2008 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)