Mountaintop Removal Hot Topic At Conference
Mountaintop Removal Hot Topic At Conference Save Email Print
Posted: 5:32 PM Apr 27, 2007
Last Updated: 7:43 PM Apr 27, 2007
Reporter: Jon Sonnheim
Email Address: jon.sonnheim@wymtnews.com

A | A | A

Mountaintop removal is just one of many topics being talked about at the East Kentucky Leadership Conference Friday.

It's the rugged mountains, the geography of Eastern Kentucky, that many people say draws them to live in this region. Imagine the irony then that it's those same rugged mountains, those valleys, which limits the region's economic development.

"We have to move with the needs of the people and we have to change to improve," said Hazard Mayor Bill Gorman.

For some, that change means using mountaintop removal as a way to not only produce coal, but utilize the finished and reclaimed land to develop the region with airports, businesses, and jobs.

"It generates 52 percent of the nation's energy and 91 percent of the state's energy, so it is the workhorse that drives our economy," said Brian Patton with James River Coal Service Company.

"The idea is not to sweep the mountains away. Level the mountain off, to where it's a usable product," Gorman said.

But for those opposed to mountaintop removal...

"We've seen mudslides, we've lost our drinking water," said Brenda Urias.

The harm to the environment they call home is far more hazardous than the economic benefits.

"They're destroying the whole ecology. Nothing will grow on that mountaintop," said Truman Hurt.

So in a culture known for its mountains, could both sides find a level playing field?? Should the environment take precedence over the economy or are some making mountains out of molehills??

More Stories
Light Snow Accumulations Possible Today, Tonight

Budget Shortfall Looms Large For Legislature

Silver Stars Presented To Father & Son War Heroes

Teacher Found Dead on Campus

Postal Workers Accused Of Stealing Mail

UT Will Introduce Kiffin On Monday

Fort Campbell Braces For Soldier Homecoming

Local Retail Store Managers Say Black Friday Went Better Than Expected

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: tiffany Location: ohio on Jan 8, 2008 at 01:27 PM
you are rteally amazing...............

Posted by: Eugenia Potter Location: Lousiville on May 1, 2007 at 09:14 PM
In Jon Sonnheim’s report on the East KY Leadership Conference last Friday, he quotes Hazard Mayor Bill Gorman, "We have to move with the needs of the people and we have to change to improve." I have been there and seen with my own eyes. When it comes to MTR, there is no change that improves a square inch of land. Instead,I saw blasted off tops of mountains that had been there for thousands of years. Then the coal is removed and the waste is shoved over the hillside, often clogging streams that were once home to fish and wildlife. Sonnheim poses: Should the environment take precedence over the economy or are some making mountains out of molehills? Let’s not forget that when chemical companies at Calvert City were dumping contaminated waste into the river, the Chamber of Commerce and the Paducah Sun called the naysayers crazy – and worse. And we all know what happened at the Paducah Diffusion Plant. Environmental justice appears to be almost unknown by Kentucky officialdom. As I sat and listened to the people of Leslie County and surrounding counties tell me about the discrimination against Appalachia, it was embarrassing. They were right: this would not happen in my neighborhood in Jefferson County! There is a long line of Kentuckians who no longer believe the big lie that coal is a cheap source of energy and who are no longer willing to have homes and lives sacrificed for coal company profits. MR. SONNHEIM: THEY’RE MAKING MOLEHILLS OUT OF MOUNTAINS.

Posted by: Sue Location: Berea on May 1, 2007 at 03:16 PM
Bill Caylor loves to tell us not to get emotional about mountaintop removal mining. But if we aren't emotional about the complete destruction of our land, water and heritage, what kind of human beings are we?

Posted by: Allan Location: Louisville on May 1, 2007 at 12:52 PM
There are plenty of justifications for removing the mountain tops. Easy of getting to the coal, and making level ground for urban development, to name a couple. All the justifications are economic. History may judge the destruction of the mountains and their environment as selfish and shortsighted.

Posted by: carl shoupe Location: benham,ky on May 1, 2007 at 12:01 PM
a friend who lives just above cumberland had a beautiful pond he spent probably 6,000.00 dollars constructing,not counting fish,aquatic growth,Nally & Hamilton a srip mine operation destroyed it. A noncompliance order was issued against the mining operation(order no.23-0065 file no.PAC28184-11) the company was fined 2,200 they paid the fine. The water

Posted by: Erica Location: Phyllis, KY on May 1, 2007 at 08:57 AM
I'm wasn't born or raised in Eastern KY but I married a man from here and this is where I now call home. It has become very dear to me and I want to raise my daughter here. I never thought about where and how we got our electricity until I came here. Destroying our mountains is not a way to justify the means of have electricity. There are other alternatives that Eastern KY could invest in that would promote growth in this area. Coal is not a renewable source. Once it is gone, it's gone. We need to stop destorying our mountains, hertiages, communities, burying our streams, killing Eastern KY. Put a stop to Mountain Top Removal NOW not 5 or 10 years on down the road but NOW.

Posted by: David Location: Middleburg, Fl. on Apr 30, 2007 at 05:47 PM
Mountain top removal destroys the beauty and the culture of Eastern Kentucky. Those mountains and the clear streams is a memory to a boy that was born and raised in Eastern Kentucky. There has to be a better way to mine coal then destroying the mountains and streams. If Kentucky taxes were not the way they are then maybe more industry would move into the region. I hope those elected and have the power to create laws will protect Eastern Kentucky heritage and save the mountains. I would like to move back and have grandchildren to experience the mountains of Kentucky where I once and still do, call Eastern Kentucky home.

AP Video
WYMT Special Sections
Issues & Answers
Host Neil Middleton gets the answers you want.
Jim's Weather Class
Want to understand the hows and whys of weather?
Holiday Gift Guide
Looking for great gift ideas?
?
Lawyers
FREE legal advice.
Refrigerator Art
Share your works of art.
Student Achiever
Honoring outstanding students in our community.
Health
What you need to know about your health.
Business Connections
Connecting businesses and customers.
Focus on the Family
Help your family thrive.
Classifieds
THE place to buy and sell items. Most ads free.
Stocks
QUOTES
    Symbol Lookup

WKYT Mobile